Make-Ahead Turkey ~ Yes You Can!

There are people who wake up in the middle of the night to begin cooking their turkey for a holiday meal. There are people who baste and stuff and rub down their bird. These people are so very nice and dedicated to poultry perfection.

And then there’s me.

huge turkey 1

That is one huge bird.
Read the whole tale here.

I cannot find it within myself to do any of this to my turkey. I’m just not as devoted of a holiday baker as some. I’m a plop the bird in a pan, add nothing to it, cover it, put it in the oven, and take it out a few hours later kind of girl.

And…my favorite turkey baking tip of all: I cook my bird before the holiday. Like, two days before, usually.

I bake it, de-bone it, prepare all the broth, dispose of the carcass – basically I do all the messy, tedious, laborious turkey work ahead of time. Then on the day of the holiday feast, I take out my big dish of cooked meat, pour on a little broth, cover it, rewarm it, and we eat it. This is stress-free turkey baking.

My turkey always still tastes delicious.

That’s why I keep doing it this way.

No, our table doesn’t hold a big un-carved turkey. There is no turkey carving tradition at our house. For those who love traditions like this, I say go for it! Baste and carve and enjoy that special tradition.

But for those who find the turkey to be tedious, you might instead consider making it ahead of time.

But won’t the meat be dry?

Not if you don’t over-bake it in the first place.

The trick is to drizzle broth over your cooked, de-boned meat (I’d say one-two cups of broth per 9×13 inch dish full of meat), then cover the dish well. I warm it on Thanksgiving day for 30-45 minutes in a 300-350° oven along with other dishes that are baking. I pull it out and have a steaming, moist, delicious pan of turkey.

Make-Ahead Turkey

Yum

4.7 from 3 reviews
Make-Ahead Turkey
 
Author:
Ingredients
  • 1 Turkey
  • 1 Large Roasting Pan
  • Foil if necessary
Instructions
  1. Place the turkey in the refrigerator for 3-4 days until thawed.
  2. Remove the bag of giblets from the inside of the turkey.
  3. Empty the giblets into your roasting pan as they help make a good, rich broth.
  4. Place the bird, breast side up, into a large baking pan or roaster.
  5. Cover with foil or with your roaster lid.
  6. Cook at 325° for 15-20 minutes per pound.
  7. You know your turkey is done cooking when the red thing pops up, or when the legs start to pull away from the body. It should be golden brown and slightly crisp looking.
  8. Be sure to save the broth that formed naturally!
  9. Allow the turkey to cool, then de-bone completely. Store meat in baggies or in covered pyrex dishes in the refrigerator.
  10. Save turkey carcass to make another round of broth for gravy, soup, and other nourishing meals.
  11. On serving day, drizzle a liberal amount of broth (one-two cups per 9x13 inch pan of meat) over turkey, cover and warm in 300°-350° oven for 30-45 minutes or until meat is hot and steamy.
  12. Serve right away.

Simple Make-Ahead Turkey ~ Easy, Moist, Delicious

Additional Turkey Tips:

  • Adding a few onions to the turkey while baking is an effortless way to add more flavor.
  • Be sure to save the broth that forms naturally while your bird bakes.
  • Do not wait until your turkey is cold to take the meat off the bones. This makes the job much harder!
  • After you’ve taken all the meat off the bones, save the bones and put them into a stock pot. Fill the pot with water, carrots, onions, and any other veggies you like. Salt liberally. Cook on low for 4-6 hours to create a wonderful broth. Strain out bones. Blend the veggies until smooth and stir them back into the broth for added richness.
  • Use turkey broth for gravy. Use it to make Turkey and Noodles a few days after Thanksgiving. Use it for any soup or recipe that calls for chicken broth.
  • While making your turkey ahead of time is wonderfully helpful in cutting down work on your holiday meal serving day, you don’t want to make it too far in advance! I recommend making it on Tuesday or Wednesday, then serving it on Thanksgiving Thursday.

What’s your turkey tradition? To carve, or not to carve? To baste, or not to baste? Ever made a turkey ahead of time?

Here are the quick links to all the recipes we covered in this series:

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Simple Meals is here! It’s saving my brain (and many of yours too!). If you haven’t joined yet, now’s the time. Get all the details here!

728x90

Comments

  1. Julie says

    I will have to share this post with my mom. She is usually responsible for the turkey and gets up at a ridiculous hour to get it into the over. Thank you for the tips!

    [Reply]

  2. R says

    I’ve never done a turkey ahead of time. Actually, my brother is the expert; he grills it, and I can’t get even close to the flavor he gets out of it!

    [Reply]

  3. Kathy T says

    I have always baked the day of. This year, tho? New (to us) house, new (to us) State, and new (to us) tradition of baking the turkey ahead of time! Hmmmm. I wonder where the roaster is packed?

    [Reply]

  4. says

    I was in charge of turkey one year and ugh… I don’t like it because of the tedious work. Next year they put me on cheesy grits. I thought “grits at thanksgiving?” But no, these are the best grits ever!

    [Reply]

  5. says

    My aunt made her turkey ahead of time last Thanksgiving and warmed it in the crockpot with broth the day of our big family gathering. It stayed warm all day so we could piece off of it. It was delicious! I’ll definitely be doing this in a few weeks!

    [Reply]

  6. says

    I love this idea! So smart! I hate making space for the turkey when I need to bake other things. Plus, the carving is always so messy! We are totally adopting this method. :)

    [Reply]

  7. Sarah says

    My husband is completely against the day before. Thinks it will be to dry. I’ll have to try again to convince him because it sure would be simple.

    [Reply]

  8. Rachel Anna says

    I’ve never made the turkey ahead of time, but we usually have pretty casual holidays without any non-immediate family members. If we were having a big group for thanksgiving, I would definitely want to try this method!

    [Reply]

  9. alexa says

    I’ve done this with chickens but never a turkey. We like to cook the stuffing in the turkey, so its always the day of. We carve in the kitchen though. I prefer to keep the knives off the dinner table. :)

    [Reply]

  10. Su says

    Sounds like a great way to cook the turkey. It’s so hard on Thanksgiving because everything else that needs to go in the oven to cook must wait. I like the tip about how to make turkey broth with the bones…thanks!

    [Reply]

  11. Rhonda says

    The last two years I have baked our turkey the day before Thanksgiving. I even make the gravy and cover the meat with it. Everyone says it’s the best, moist and tender. I can’t believe I didn’t think of it years ago. :-)

    [Reply]

  12. Cheryl says

    I may have beenthe only one thinking, I should make two or three and put it in pans in the freezer for quick winter meals.

    [Reply]

    Karen Sexton Reply:

    I am thinking this….. and am cooking one today. I got two, buy one get one free from the store.

    [Reply]

  13. Heather says

    Last year I cooked a turkey that looks like the one you pictured (or maybe even bigger?) Those farm raised birds get big…I think ours was 35 pounds or so and not even close to the biggest one they grew! I did the low and slow method and it went in the night before. It turned out really good, but this method would be awesome for saving the clean up on a busy kitchen day. My only fear would be losing the awesome smell of a cooking turkey. That is the perfume of Thanksgiving to me :) And we froze a ton of meat from that bird. We ate turkey all winter!

    [Reply]

    Christine Reply:

    How big is your oven? Where in the world did you find a pan to fit a 35 lb turkey? I have a standard oven and there’s no way a 35 lb turkey would fit in it.

    [Reply]

  14. says

    Good Morning, Laura!

    Over the past few weeks, I’ve been praying about a way that I could encourage other bloggers who have been encouraging me. Through your ministry, posts, words, comments, and faithfulness—your life has been a blessing to mine, and I wanted others to know about you!

    So, I compiled a list of those bloggers who I’ve personally found to be the MOST INSPIRATIONAL on the web.

    You are ONE Of these bloggers – in my estimation!

    You can find the link to the list where you are featured here: http://www.melanieredd.com/the-100-most-inspiring-christian-blogs-on-the-web/

    I’ve also signed up to get your emails, and tried to follow you on your social media outlets!

    I pray that God will encourage you today through these simple acts~
    Melanie

    [Reply]

  15. Suz says

    I’m with Julie-I will share this tip with my mom; that turkey mess is always such a drain on Thanksgiving Day (now to convince my dad that it’ll be ok…). Thanks!

    [Reply]

  16. Karen H. says

    I’m with you, Laura. Making the turkey ahead of time is what I do, too. I have never tried pouring broth over the meat before putting it in the fridge, but I do save the skin during carving and lay it back over the meat before putting the cover on my pyrex dish. That really seems to help.

    [Reply]

  17. Susan says

    I am definitely using this method of turkey prep this year. It will significantly reduce kitchen chaos on Thanksgiving. Thank you for the stress-reducing method!

    [Reply]

  18. Jill says

    We have one of the fellows in charge of the turkey – either dad or my brother. And we grill it or deep fry it outside . That frees up the oven for the other dishes, keeps the kitchen a bit cooler, allows everyone to sleep til a reasonable hour.

    Cooking it on the grill or outdoor fryer has the added bonus of reminding the men-folk how much WORK goes into putting on a nice spread since they are the ones running out in our Wisconsin snow to check the grill/fryer.

    I also come from a huge family so we do dinner potluck style so no one person is overwhelmed with cooking, hosting, and clean up duties. It’s great!

    [Reply]

  19. Julie says

    This is how my mom made her turkey dinners and she always received compliments. The meat was always moist and tasty. Thanks got the reminder!

    [Reply]

  20. Emily says

    We’ve done something similar for years out of necessity. There are so many of us at the holidays we need more than one turkey, plus we usually do a ham as well!

    [Reply]

  21. says

    You are right on the money, Laura! When I host Thanksgiving or Christmas dinner I generally roast the turkey ahead of time unless we are doing deep-fried turkey for that meal. I’ll also buy multiple 20+ pound turkeys on sale at this time of year for my family of four to use as meat throughout the year. Like you, when I prepare a turkey I’ll cook it in the roaster, debone it, save the broth, then either make stock right away or freeze the carcass for future stock-making. I add some broth to the turkey meat like you said and freeze it for future meals. I use turkey in recipes just like I’d use chicken. My husband loves turkey, so he thinks this method is great because it means he gets turkey more often. ;)

    [Reply]

  22. Karen says

    Last year I had to cook turkeys for our church dinner which was a few weeks before Thanksgiving. I put the leftovers in the freezer. I took it out for my family’s Thanksgiving and added leftover broth (also previously frozen) to reheat it. It was great. No complaints, and less work for me that day.

    [Reply]

  23. Kim says

    I’ll have to pass this along to my mom. Luckily for me, my family goes to her house every year and I don’t have to cook.

    [Reply]

  24. Vicky says

    I bake my turkey ahead of time too. Instead of reheating in the oven I use my crock pot. That way I have oven space available.

    [Reply]

  25. Mich says

    Well what a new idea! Great way to make sure the turkey is cooked all the way for Thanksgiving! Last year I guess ours was still a little frozen in the middle- and it didn’t get done until a few hours after the dinner. Wouldn’t happen with this!

    [Reply]

  26. Courtney Wagner says

    I absolutely love this idea. I always feel like it’s hard to enjoy Thanksgiving because there is so much work to do. I want to try getting all the big jobs done before the big day!

    [Reply]

  27. Amanda says

    Love this idea! We’re going a slightly different route this Thanksgiving and deep frying our turkey! Might be a little more labor intensive, but I think it’ll be worth it this year – the kids are all looking forward to the whole experience.

    [Reply]

  28. Charlotte Moore says

    It works great to freeze with some of the broth to use later too. I freeze it smaller servings too. The broth helps it not to taste warmed over to me.

    [Reply]

  29. Robin says

    We cook it the day before Thanksgiving. Then, we reheat some of it and leave some for those who prefer to eat it cold.

    [Reply]

  30. Christine says

    I forgot you cook your turkey ahead. I usually cook a large breast for the 4 of us because I don’t like dealing with carving a turkey at the end of the day. Could you make this post earlier next year for those of us who plan our menus far in advance? I cooked most of my Thanksgiving dinner in August and froze it since my parents are coming for a week. I’ve already planned to marinate and cook two breasts.

    [Reply]

  31. Deb says

    Great idea! I have a small enough group to get away with doing just a turkey breast in my crock pot, but I will be using this idea next time (and for chickens in the mean time). Thanks, Laura!

    [Reply]

  32. Kristi says

    Thanks for all the great tips on how to treat the turkey after it’s cooked for use later. I just have one thing to add — avoid the whole defrosting mess in the fridge by cooking it frozen. I’ve done this the last couple years. It could not be easier and it turns out great! The theory is the breast doesn’t dry out because it takes longer to thaw and so the timing works out perfectly with the smaller dark meat pieces getting done. I just know it works and it saves a lot of potential germs all over the kitchen storing and handling a raw bird for multiple days.

    http://blog.williams-sonoma.com/yes-you-can-roast-a-frozen-turkey/

    [Reply]

  33. Donna says

    Started cooking my turkeys ahead of time about five years ago. I would never go back to cooking it the day of with all the mess and craziness!

    [Reply]

  34. Ashleigh says

    We use a rotisserie to cook our turkey day of. The skin gets crisp, the turkey is moist, and it doesn’t take more than a couple hours to cook. The two problems though are you still have the mess day of and our rotisserie doesn’t hold more than a 12-lb bird. It’s tastes really good though!!

    [Reply]

  35. Melissa M. says

    I am in charge of the ham at the holidays and have been doing this for a couple of years, but never thought to do this to turkey!

    What caught my eye in this post was your brief mention of making turkey bone stock and blending the vegetables back into the broth. I recently accidentally made some awesome veggie broth with carrots and broccoli and wanted to repeat it but didn’t want to dispose of the veggies. Now I know what to do!

    [Reply]

  36. Brighid says

    Our turkey tradition is to say “Oh that looks delicious!” and keep complimenting my sister-in-law and brother who typically make the turkey. :) For the past 5 or 6 years, we’ve all made a portion of the meal so no one is overwhelmed.

    [Reply]

  37. Renee Whitman says

    Turkey is pretty expensive here in Paraguay, but I’m tempted to see if it will be cheaper this year just so I can try this! If not, maybe I’ll just do the same with chicken.

    [Reply]

  38. Dorthy M. says

    I’m a cook all day kind of girl, especially with the turkey, but I think I’m going to cook it a day or two early this year. I like this idea. Some days really do not need all the stress.

    [Reply]

  39. Melissa says

    Typically we have done Thanksgiving dinner at our house and cooked the day of. Last year my parents moved closer and now we celebrate at their house!

    [Reply]

  40. Dee says

    I’m thinking of trying a cooking bag for my turkey this year. Does anyone have experience with those? Does the turkey turn out good flavor and brown and moist? I would think clean up would be much easier too? Although I don’t think you would get a crispy skin, but maybe open the bag at the end to crisp it up a bit, or would that dry it out? Can you add veggies to the bag with the turkey too, or does that affect doneness in that area of the bird?

    [Reply]

  41. Kimberly says

    Laura, I LOVE this idea and saving the bones & adding veggies sounds wonderful. My mama used to make Turkey Pot Pie with the leftovers every year. I’m sure the stock will come in handy for that. I sure do miss my mama. :(
    One reason I enjoy your blog so much is it reminds me of her. You are a real blessing to me. I hope that you & yours have a wonderful Thanksgiving. God Bless you! <3

    [Reply]

  42. Julie says

    I tried this two Thanksgivings ago when we had such a large crowd we needed a turkey and an additional turkey breast. There was no way I had oven space for all that turkey and the other parts of the meal. Making the turkey in advance worked so well I did it again last year when we had a much smaller crowd. No more worrying about if the turkey would be done in time. No more trying to fit way too many pans into one oven. No more calling hubby away from guests to carve the turkey.
    Reheating the turkey produces the same scents as cooking the turkey does. No one noticed the difference in technique.

    [Reply]

  43. says

    How is it that I’ve never considered baking the turkey ahead of time?! I will have to try that next year when we cook it. This year, I work the days leading up to Thanksgiving and won’t have the time to do it in advance. Thank you for the awesome post!

    [Reply]

  44. Brenda tanner says

    This is what I do also cook before ,debone carve, then reheat with broth.I love the name heavenlyhomemakers,so glad I found you!

    [Reply]

  45. Pam D says

    Thank you, thank you, thank you! I cooked my turkey nearly a week before Christmas, deboned it, and froze it in baggies. After thawing and reheating it in 2 cups of broth, it was so delicious. I think I would go so far as to say that it was the most moist and flavorful turkey I have ever eaten. Thank you so much for all of your helpful tips.

    [Reply]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe: